The Channel logo

News

By | Paul Kunert 10th June 2013 13:19

HMRC ordered to cough up compo for winding-up petition, says Enta

Telford-based distie was victim of 'Civil Service Syndrome'

Enta Technologies has claimed that a judgment given at the Royal Courts of Justice (RCJ) last week ordered HMRC to compensate it over a gaffe related to a winding-up petition.

As revealed by El Chan, the London Gazette erroneously stated on 29 May that HMRC had issued a winding-up petition against the tech distie, to be heard at the Royal Courts of Justice (RCJ) on 10 June.

The notice was subsequently retracted a day later but the matter was not resolved.

Enta chairman Jason Tsai revealed today the petition was connected to a supposed claim from the taxman for £1m worth of VAT repayments, but said this was due to a misunderstanding over inter company trading.

He told us it met with HMRC last week to discuss the situation but said officials wanted two weeks to consider their position.

"That would have made our suppliers nervous so we wanted to go straight to court to get the petition struck off," he told The Channel.

The case was heard at the Royal Courts on 6 June and dismissed by the judge, a development that was noted by the Gazette on 7 June.

"The whole episode can be described as 'Civil Servants Syndrome,'"said Tsai. "There is no accountability when civil servants make mistakes," he added.

He claimed HMRC should not have placed the petition, and in recognition of this, the RCJ has "ordered HMRC to compensate Enta for all legal costs incurred in defending the petition".

An HMRC solicitor confirmed the petition was "no longer live" but refused to comment further.

HMRC's press person told us that it could not comment on individual company cases. ®

alert Send corrections

Opinion

Ship scrapyard photo via Shutterstock
Windows 10 Universal Apps
Windows 10 on Surface 3

Tim Anderson

It's do-or-die for Microsoft's new operating system on 29 July

Features

Steve Ballmer. Pic:  Aanjhan Ranganathan
Nokia is the biggest write-off yet, but it wasn't the first
Confused computer keyboard
Last Christmas, I gave you my Cloud, the very next day you gave it away
Time to pull out the magnifying glass to swot up on those Ts&Cs
Android icon desktop toys
Nice devices, now speak 'enterprise' to me