The Channel logo


By | Bill Ray 26th January 2012 11:14

Apple and Google ramp up proxy war

Motorola flings another 6 patent suits at the Fruity One

Apple and Google might not be facing each other across a courtroom, but they're fighting just the same, with the Chocolate Factory wielding Motorola against the fondleslab-maker.

Motorola has filed another half dozen patent infringements against Apple, this time in Florida (Texas is probably full). Apple's iCloud is accused of infringing two of them, while all six are applied to the iPhone 4s. But our old friend Florian Mueller has noticed that the acquisition agreement signed by Motorola and Google means this action could not have gone ahead without written permission from the Chocolate Factory.

During the Cold War, superpowers reluctant to pit themselves against each other would commonly back provincial wars in often-hard-to-pronounce countries. Here they could let off steam and generally give each other a bit of a shoeing without destroying the earth in the process. Those of us still alive appreciate the outlet such wars provided, but it was a bit tough on the people in those countries.

It's an easy comparison to see Apple and Google as doing much the same thing, though Apple is directly involved and Google is being drawn in no matter how it tries to distance itself.

But for this round it's Motorola that is demanding the usual ban on all iPhone sales, and immediate shutting down of the iCloud service, together with the normal hyperbole about commercial damages.

The objectives of each side in the bigger battle aren't entirely the same. Apple wants to see Android destroyed, or at least fatally wounded, while Google's side wants Apple to leave it alone and, perhaps, pay some royalties, but that's not the priority.

By acquiring Motorola's handset division, Google is drawing itself into the fight, making a final showdown between the two companies inevitable. ®

comment icon Read 22 comments on this article alert Send corrections


George Osborne, photo: HM Treasury
shutterstock_183801788_container ship

Chris Mellor

The SAN growth glory days are well and truly over, so where next?

Tom Whipp

Insurance industry insider tells all
Crypto fingers


Michael Dell. Pic by Joi Ito
Cool Texas dude is just your average billionaire
The Seeing Eye by Valerie Everett, Flickr, CC2.0
Follow the money – or, at least, our projections
Boats storm girl photo via Nikolina Mrakovic
The puppets from Team America: World Police gather at a bar for drinks.