The Channel logo

News

By | Anna Leach 24th January 2012 15:24

Apple's Dutch Galaxy Tab ban shot down by The Hague

Trendy tech titan takes a hit as patent war reaches The Netherlands

The Dutch have found themselves on the front line of the long-running international patent battle between Apple and Samsung: an appeals court in The Hague has rejected Apple's design-related gripes against Samsung's Galaxy Tab tablet, snubbing its request for a ban on the sale of the iPad rival in The Netherlands.

The Hague Court of Appeals upheld the ruling of a lower court denying Apple a preliminary injunction against the Galaxy Tab.

If Apple had won the preliminary injunction against Samsung, as it did in Germany last year, it could have prevented the sale of the Galaxy Tab in the The Netherlands, pending the official resolution of the court case.

After presiding over wrangles regarding the exact appearance of the two tablets and a thorough discussion of features such as dotted lines, screen icons and thickness of the device, the Dutch judge concluded that the Samsung Tablet gave a different overall impression to Apple's iPad.

Calling also on the existence of prior art – including a video promo for a tablet computer by tech firm Knight-Ridder from 1994 – the judge concluded that Apple's design rights were not invalid but that their scope should be narrowed.

The court ruling (in Dutch) is here. ®

comment icon Read 15 comments on this article alert Send corrections

Opinion

WWI French tank picture via Shutterstock
Vinod_Khosla

Chris Mellor

A VC with startup agenda slams established suppliers. Surprised? Neither were we
ZenPad_RealRacing
Boy writes a letter to Santa. Pic via Shutterstock

Kat Hall

Cornwall's win over BT should be a cautionary relationship tale

Features

Eclipse image via Shutterstock
The Azure Portal: Microsoft is betting on cloud for its future business
container_ship_hamburg_shutterstock_648
Michael Dell. Pic by Joi Ito
Cool Texas dude is just your average billionaire