The Channel logo

News

By | Kelly Fiveash 31st December 2010 11:56

US woman sues again over XP 'downgrade', seeks class action

Together we can stop this somewhat improved steamroller!

A US woman who earlier this year unsuccessfully tried to sue Microsoft for allegedly charging her extra to downgrade from Windows Vista to XP has brought another lawsuit against the software giant.

Emma Alvarado of Los Angeles, California, filed a complaint in a federal court last week, reports Computer World.

She has now accused Microsoft of breaking the city's unfair biz practice and restraint of trade laws by getting punters to buy a copy of Windows Vista or Windows 7 if they want to "downgrade" to the company's nine-year old Windows XP operating system.

Alvarado has asked a California federal judge to grant the case class-action status, allowing the opportunity for other narked-off customers to sue Microsoft, if they so wish to.

She is demanding that Microsoft refund all sales derived from its downgrade option and said in the lawsuit that any members of the class - if a judge grants the case that status - should be awarded triple any actual damages meted out.

The complainant first filed a lawsuit against Microsoft on 11 February 2009, but it was dismissed in February this year.

Alvarado, in the original suit, claimed that Microsoft violated its dominant market position by requiring consumers to buy computers pre-installed with Vista and then getting them to cough up additional cash to “downgrade” to XP.

Her complaint hinged on allegations that Microsoft forced individuals running Vista Basic to first upgrade to Vista Business or Vista Ultimate and then pay for a download licence fee for XP Professional.

The new suit, as noted by Computer World, has many similarities with the original complaint. ®

comment icon Read 92 comments on this article alert Send corrections

Opinion

Walking on water, image via Shutterstock

Chris Mellor

IDC stats reveal who's who in the backup appliance bearpit
Carry on Cleo

Gavin Clarke

Infamy, infamy, Amazon and Microsoft have all got it in for me!

Tim Anderson

Also signals stronger cross-platform tools, access to new markets

Features

Nerd fail photo via Shutterstock
Shouting match
Single market vs. rest of the world
hacker
Mostly it's financial crime. Here's what all the cool kids' terms mean in English
Apple logo. Pic: Blake Patterson
Plenty of bumps in the 40-year road for Mac makers