Channel Register

Comments on: CIO surveys murdering IT budgets

Bah, who needs an IT department these days? 

Posted Monday 3rd November 2008 21:59 GMT

Plenty of easy cloudiness available, and John from accountings knows enough about them computers to debug the PAs' desktops.

The fools.

cut or be cut? 

Posted Monday 3rd November 2008 22:31 GMT

While the magazine says that CIOs will cut their budgets next year, I think this is really just bravado. What happens in the real world is not that the CIOs cut the budgets themselves, but that the finance people do it for them.

Since CFOs unanimously think of IT as a cost centre, it's an easy target to axe all these wizzy new projects that they don't understand - and will probably not work, exceed their costs and run late anyway. Part of our problem has always been that the bean-counters simply don't understand the role of IT. It's frequently seen as a "necessary evil" and therefore marginalised. What we (all) need to do during the next upturn is to let the guardians of the monkey know how IT helps them.

Make the new motto "hug a bean counter" You never know, if you hug them hard enough, they might just stop breathing.

Lies, damn lies and statistics 

Posted Tuesday 4th November 2008 08:40 GMT

These CIO surveys are great. They tell you what people are planning to do. The major problem is that they don't tell you why.

Of course non-urgent projects are going to get stalled if the company itself is in the poo. And right now that's a lot of companies.

Anyone reading these surveys and thinking 'Golly, Example Corporation is cutting its budgets so we had better' is an idiot.

Re:not work, exceed costs and run late 

Posted Tuesday 4th November 2008 10:15 GMT

Hey ! Not everybody works for Her Majesty's government I'll have you know !! ;-)

But I love the motto. I'm go to go crush, uh, hug a bean counter right now ! I'm sure I'll find that I should have done that ages ago.

<title> 

Posted Tuesday 4th November 2008 12:32 GMT

Thumb Down

Well, there's always the hope that the costs that they decide to cut are the doomed projects, the non-functional systems that could be replaced at 1/100th the cost, or the managers who don't actually manage anything beyond getting in the way.

Yeah, fat chance. They'll blow the budget on some pile of execremental bloatware like Lotus Notes, Clearcase or Remedy in the name of process and saving money (I'm not bitter, I just quit my last place when they suggested migrating from Subversion to Clearcase).

Seriously, these CIO surveys are costing businesses a fortune, and need to be replaced with CIO types actually going and talking to their users and tecchies, rather than filling in quizzes. Those that survive the LART and the halon system should then leave with a bit more respect.

Cynical, moi?

CIOs ask for their budget 

Posted Tuesday 4th November 2008 12:40 GMT

any department can get their budget slashed including the bean counters. It depends who is at the top of the company, more often than not.

Everyone knows the trick of those who do the reporting lying to people further up the chain by now, that was so 1990s, now if you are at the top you choose who are your favourites and who you want to punish, and cut budgets accordingly.

CFOs don't have much power any more, most are in disgrace for borrowing too much, and they are often used as the reason why suppliers are not being paid, so they are hated all over their own industry.

They don't employ... 

Posted Tuesday 4th November 2008 13:27 GMT

Black Helicopters

Robert Peston on a freelance basis by any chance!

These CIO/CEO types make me go GRRRR!!!!!! 

Posted Tuesday 4th November 2008 14:19 GMT

They keep hiring stay at home moms into the IT world and I recently bumped into many who were hired and did not know how to use a mouse!

CIOs vs CFOs 

Posted Tuesday 4th November 2008 14:48 GMT

Gates Halo

I remember the good old days when the CFO was the CIO, and just had to have an automated bean counter.

Bill Gates = nostalgia icon

Expert lag time 

Posted Tuesday 4th November 2008 15:10 GMT

Unhappy

The central point is that all these analyses - economic, OECD, or recycled opinions - all assume much sameness until it becomes clear that things have changed. The current view seems to be deterioration till mid-2009 and then return to 2007 levels. This is most unlikely to be a steady-state view .

In IT terms, our experts extrapolating round the coffee machine recently found that any project worth postponing till next year won't get back on the agenda till 2013.

Excuse me posting anonymously, but I don't know which bank to put any consulting fees on offer.

We Will Be Back 

Posted Wednesday 5th November 2008 17:45 GMT

Thumb Up

Rest assured, dear readers, we will be back to survey again. As long as this financial crisis continues and CIOs have to make tough decisions and the sun also rises, we will provide context an analysis. Don't hang up on me!

Kim Nash

Senior Editor

CIO Magazine