Channel Register

Comments on: Laptop-crazy consumers will keep PC market afloat

Craaaazy Consumers 

Posted Friday 12th September 2008 00:13 GMT

Paris Hilton

It has been my experience that most "consumers" who purchase laptops have no compelling reason to have a laptop other than it is cuter/flashier/cooler etc.

This is even after they have been warned about the many, many areas where laptops are inferior to a good desktop.

Laptops are;

More expensive

Slower

Crappy keyboard

Crappy mouse

Can't be upgraded

Prone to breakage

Expensive/impossible to repair

The only advantage they have is they can be carried around, but there are tonnes of people who own laptops that may as well be glued to their desks.

Case in point, my dumb sister and her idiot teenage son.

They rang me up asking whether some Toshiba laptop they had their eye on would be good. I asked them why they thought they needed a laptop seeing that they never go anywhere, have never owned a computer before and only one of them works, and that is as a gas station attendant where having a laptop is hardly considered as being a necessary tool for the execution of ones duties. They then received the full lecture from me outlining the negative aspects of owning a laptop and went away to ponder things further.

Days later I learn that, of course, they went ahead and bought the Toshiba anyway.

Hardly a month passed before idiot teenage son decides to spill coke all over the damn thing, rendering it an ex-laptop. This is despite my often repeated express warnings after they had bought the thing to "at least make sure that nobody eats/drinks near it for gods sake"

Sigh

Some people just can't be helped.

Paris, because she's the sort of laptop I could get into

@goat 

Posted Friday 12th September 2008 10:44 GMT

Thumb Up

Ooo you fogot.

Takes up less space.

Quieter

Less Cables

Lower Power

Inbuilt UPS

also..... 

Posted Friday 12th September 2008 11:39 GMT

Thumb Up

Makes a nice hotplate.

@stu 

Posted Friday 12th September 2008 12:28 GMT

Cables: Well, this is not such an advantage once you realise you have to plug in a decent keyboard /mouse/GB ethernet for a decent user experience (plus you have to buy the extra bits to do this)

Lower Power: granted, but I would contend that that this alone is not a sufficient advantage to offset the many disadvantages presented by owning a laptop.

Inbuilt UPS. Once again this may be an advantage to some users, but one that will be completely unappreciated by the type of user that merely uses their PC to browse YouTube and send/receive the occasional email.

Let's face the facts, for 95% of users (a figure I completely pulled out of my arse I assure you) a desktop is a better choice. So, let us all ask ourselves why 95% of pc sales are not actually for desktops.

It has something to do with something as superficial and puerile as laptops being "sexier" looking I assure you.

@stu part 2 

Posted Friday 12th September 2008 12:34 GMT

Regarding the question of space;

This is a fallacy. If you consider the average desk, you can have a desktop PC on the floor and the only desk space you need to allocate is that required for a standard keyboard and a flatscreen LCD monitor which takes takes up no more desk real estate than your average laptop. If you add the external keyboard that you need to plug into your laptop then you are taking up more deskspace than just a keyboard and a flatscreen LCD.

The laptop fallacy 

Posted Friday 12th September 2008 19:52 GMT

Let's not forget the fact that people also want powerful computers, a function any reasonable soul would leave to a desktop. Netbooks do so well because people who want a mobile computer but are sane enough to leave the heavy lifting to the desktop are buying them.

may sound silly 

Posted Sunday 14th September 2008 23:12 GMT

But i'm quite convinced, many people (subconciously?) also see a laptop as a smaller threat, eg that big tower thing looks much less controllable than a small brick on your desk. hah, as if.

My laptop workstation 

Posted Monday 15th September 2008 11:19 GMT

Happy

There is a ledge 20 cm above my desk for my Dell laptop with the 15" display.

On my desk is either a USB IBM Trackpad keyboard or a wireless Keyboard and mouse combo. (Depending on what continent I'm on. I haven't decided which setup works best and I can switch without changing the laptop.)

This way I have one of the nicer displays in our office at a comfortable viewing level and it keeps my palms away from that fraking touchy pad.

But I suspect that China will take over the Cute and Cramped Subnotebook market, leaving the big American PC companies beached with the tide out.

@F Seiler and the Laptop Threat 

Posted Tuesday 23rd September 2008 20:14 GMT

I think you are correct. The "big hulking box" at their desk can be intimidating, but the portable laptop is viewed just like their iPod or SmartPhone (which they don't leverage either).

That being said, I prefer my laptop. Yes it costs lots of money to buy a new one every year or so ($30k+ since '01) but it doesn't matter because I can take my laptop to all my regular work areas (office, home, field offices) and plug it in to my choice of monitor/printer setups that remains standardized throughout my spaces without the risk of some fucking "cloud" being blown away by a strong breeze. I have no security concerns and it makes me look cooler. All the developers at our shop use laptops for the same reasons. Granted, they aren't very cool, but their laptops are nice.

It's like the Washington Post "if you don't get it - you don't get it". Ha.

Don’t Miss

Pirates ahoy!Sign up, sign up for The Register IT security newsletter

Narrowcasting for the email classes

SunFormer top Sun exec mourns end of a franchise

Watermelons, Elton John, and killing SGI

HTC Touch Diamond 2Win an HTC Touch Diamond2!

Reg Lucky Draw Last call for iPhone botherer promo

thumbs down teaser 75Disties braced for autumn reseller collapses

Is that why they call it fall?