The European Commission has proposed extending the provisional ecommerce tax to give it more time to push through permanent legislation.

Agreed in 2003 on the proviso that it would be "revisited" again by the end of June this year, the rules controversially imposed VAT on firms selling into the EU, but exempted European firms selling outside EU borders.

Critics of the tax wanted a moratorium applied to electronic sales to promote a growing ecommerce industry. The EC argued this would discriminate against existing businesses that had worked hard and paid taxes for too many generations to mention.

To imagine how a moratorium would have panned out for good old fashioned shops and traders, consider what fortunes befell importing ecommerce upstarts under the old rules.

Before 2003, anyone selling into the EU electronically could avoid paying VAT. This on the one hand, was great news for anyone who wanted to buy cheap books and CDs. But it was bad news too, as many of the same consumers would later lament, because it encouraged the dominance of US behemoth's like Amazon and the decline of traditional indigenous retail businesses. ®

Related stories

• Amazon profits fall push shares down (26 July 2006)
• E-tailers can still shop for best VAT regime (12 June 2006)
• Commission proposes ecommerce VAT rule extension (30 May 2006)
• EU self-flagellates over ICT strategy (22 May 2006)
• Euro judges back HMRC on VAT fraud (12 May 2006)
• VAT scams 'cost UK £5bn' in last fiscal year - claim (9 May 2006)
• Dot-coms' VAT-swerve hurts small biz (8 November 2005)
• Letters VAT on email troubles Reg readers (6 May 2005)
• Sending data by email: a govt licence to print money (5 May 2005)
• EU to turn US e-tailers into Euro tax gatherers (21 April 2001)