Companies unwittingly ensnared in VAT fraud schemes can reclaim frozen VAT refunds thanks to a judgement by the European Court of Justice.

The court today issued its judgement on Bond House Systems’ appeal, along with two other firms, against HM Revenue & Customs' rulings, under which their VAT rebates were frozen when they became unwitting victims of carousel frauds.

The court ruled that a company's deduction of VAT, “cannot be affected by the fact that in the chain of supply of which those transactions form part, without that taxable person knowing or having any means of knowing, another prior or subsequent transaction is vitiated by VAT fraud.”

Bond House was effectively forced to cease trading after losing a 2003 appeal against a tribunal decision on HMRC’s decision to withheld £13m of rebates. Many other companies – many in electronics distribution – were hit by such frauds, with customs withholding £210m in rebates in 2003-2004 alone.®

Related stories

• VAT fraud drives booming UK exports (25 July 2006)
• Computing VAT regime will be turned on its head, says EU Commissioner (14 July 2006)
• VAT fraudster gets six years (19 June 2006)
• EC backs UK tax man on VAT fraud (1 June 2006)
• Euro judges back HMRC on VAT fraud (12 May 2006)
• VAT scams 'cost UK £5bn' in last fiscal year - claim (9 May 2006)
• Missing traders leave hole in VAT receipts (25 April 2006)
• Online CD sellers may lose offshore haven (1 March 2006)
• UK goes into reverse on VAT fraud fight (27 January 2006)
• Four found guilty of £40m VAT fraud (17 August 2005)
• VAT fraud changes shape of trade deficit (10 August 2005)
• Judge slates Customs in £120m VAT fraud case (24 June 2005)
• Jury clears businessman in VAT fraud case (23 May 2005)
• Customs loses VAT weapon (21 February 2005)
• Dealers win High Court VAT action against Customs (9 March 2004)